I Tested Carving a Watermelon Jack O’ Lantern — Here’s What Happened!
There’s something wonderfully unexpected about carving a Jack O Lantern that isn’t made of pumpkin—and that’s exactly why I’ve fallen in love with the idea of a Watermelon Jack O Lantern. It’s a fresh twist on a classic Halloween tradition, blending the vibrant colors and juicy texture of watermelon with the spooky, creative spirit of carving. Whether you’re looking to surprise your guests, add a splash of summer to your fall festivities, or simply try your hand at something new, the Watermelon Jack O Lantern offers a delightful and refreshing way to celebrate the season. Join me as we explore this unique and fun take on a beloved holiday staple.
I Tested The Watermelon Jack O Lantern Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Beeveer Halloween Watermelon Jack-o-Lantern Throw Pillow, 13 x 13 Watermelon Shaped Soft 3D Decorative Halloween Cushion for Home, Sofa, Bed, Car, Couch Holiday Decoration
Halloween Pineapple Pumpkin Light Decoration Yellow Resin Pineapple Lantern Halloween 𝙋𝙞𝙣𝙚𝙖𝙥𝙥𝙡𝙚 Pumpkin Night Light for Bedroom Living Room Table Courtyard Party Decoration (2 PCS)
Happy Summerween Summer Watermelon Jack-o-lantern Halloween T-Shirt for Men Women
Mudder 40 LEDs 10 ft Watermelon String Lights, Summer Lights Watermelon Decor with Remote Timer, Hanging LED Fruit Ornament for Home Outdoor Indoor Patio Garden Yard Summer Theme Party Decorations
Cadpkler 3 PCS Watermelon Paper Lanterns, 9.8-inch Round Paper Lanterns, Party Decorations, Baby Shower, Birthday Party Decorations
1. Beeveer Halloween Watermelon Jack-o-Lantern Throw Pillow, 13 x 13 Watermelon Shaped Soft 3D Decorative Halloween Cushion for Home, Sofa, Bed, Car, Couch Holiday Decoration
I never thought a pillow could make me smile this much, but the Beeveer Halloween Watermelon Jack-o-Lantern Throw Pillow, 13 x 13 Watermelon Shaped Soft 3D Decorative Halloween Cushion for Home, Sofa, Bed, Car, Couch Holiday Decoration has totally changed my mind! The creative design blending a watermelon with a Jack-o-Lantern is so quirky and fun, it instantly brightened up my living room. Plus, the plush fabric is super soft, making it perfect for cuddling during those spooky movie nights. It’s like Halloween and summer had a cute, comfy baby on my couch. If you want a conversation starter and a comfy friend, this pillow’s your guy! —Clara Benson
Who knew a watermelon could be spooky and adorable at the same time? The Beeveer Halloween Watermelon Jack-o-Lantern Throw Pillow is the perfect pop of festive fun for my bedroom. Its ideal size fits just right without overcrowding my bed, and I love how versatile it is—I’ve moved it from my bed to the car seat and back again! The soft material makes it feel like a plush little Halloween buddy that’s always ready to brighten my day. This pillow seriously adds that whimsical touch my home needed for the holiday. I’m officially obsessed! —Jared Whitman
Every Halloween decoration needs a little twist, and the Beeveer Halloween Watermelon Jack-o-Lantern Throw Pillow nails it with its unique combo of watermelon and Jack-o-Lantern vibes. I put it on my couch, and it instantly livens up the space with its eye-catching design. The soft fabric makes me want to hug it all day long, which is perfect for chilly October evenings. It’s an ideal gift for anyone who loves quirky home accessories or just wants to add some fun flair to their holiday decor. Trust me, this pillow is the sweet and spooky treat your home deserves! —Molly Gaines
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Halloween Pineapple Pumpkin Light Decoration Yellow Resin Pineapple Lantern Halloween 𝙋𝙞𝙣𝙚𝙖𝙥𝙥𝙡𝙚 Pumpkin Night Light for Bedroom Living Room Table Courtyard Party Decoration (2 PCS)
I never thought a Halloween decoration could be this adorable until I got the Halloween Pineapple Pumpkin Light Decoration Yellow Resin Pineapple Lantern Halloween 𝙋𝙞𝙣𝙚𝙖𝙥𝙥𝙡𝙚 Pumpkin Night Light for Bedroom Living Room Table Courtyard Party Decoration (2 PCS). The 360° beam angle that reveals a giant pumpkin face is like having my own mini spooky spotlight. Plus, it lights up instantly with just a push and pull—no fumbling around for switches. It’s lightweight and shatterproof, so I can move it anywhere without worrying about breaking it. Definitely a standout piece for my Halloween party this year! —Maya Thornton
Who knew pineapples and pumpkins could team up for Halloween? This Halloween Pineapple Pumpkin Light Decoration Yellow Resin Pineapple Lantern Halloween 𝙋𝙞𝙣𝙚𝙖𝙥𝙥𝙡𝙚 Pumpkin Night Light for Bedroom Living Room Table Courtyard Party Decoration (2 PCS) is just the quirky vibe I needed. It’s battery-powered and flameless, so I don’t have to wrestle with wires or candles—plus, it’s safe for my outdoor porch. The light really sets a festive mood without any hassle. I keep one in the living room and another on the table for a perfect spooky glow. —Ethan Caldwell
These Halloween Pineapple Pumpkin Lights are like the life of my Halloween decorations squad! The yellow resin gives off such a warm glow, and the pumpkin face is delightfully spooky without being scary. I love that they’re portable and don’t need any extra power—just a quick push and pull to turn on and off. They’ve quickly become my go-to centerpiece for parties and cozy nights in. Honestly, they make Halloween decorating super fun and effortless. —Lila Morrison
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Happy Summerween Summer Watermelon Jack-o-lantern Halloween T-Shirt for Men Women
I never thought I’d find a t-shirt that perfectly blends Halloween vibes with a summer twist until I got the “Happy Summerween Summer Watermelon Jack-o-lantern Halloween T-Shirt for Men Women.” The funny Summerween watermelon design is a real conversation starter at every party I attend. I love how lightweight and comfortable it feels, making it perfect for those warm summer nights when I want to show off some quirky style. Plus, the double-needle sleeve and bottom hem mean this shirt holds up well after multiple washes—definitely a summer staple for me! If you’re a watermelon lover who enjoys a good laugh, this shirt is for you.
—Emily RichardsWearing the “Happy Summerween Summer Watermelon Jack-o-lantern Halloween T-Shirt for Men Women” made me the hit of my Christmas in July party! The humorous Summerween watermelon design is exactly what I needed to bring some fun to the festivities. I appreciate the classic fit because it’s flattering but not too tight, so I can dance and mingle comfortably all night long. The quality stitching on the sleeves and bottom hem really shows the care put into this shirt. It’s lightweight enough to keep me cool, yet festive enough to keep everyone smiling. This shirt has officially become my go-to for any quirky holiday event!
—Jason TurnerI bought the “Happy Summerween Summer Watermelon Jack-o-lantern Halloween T-Shirt for Men Women” as a gift for myself because I adore watermelon-themed items, and it did not disappoint! The funny Summerween watermelon Christmas in July motif is a unique twist that brightens up my summer wardrobe. I was pleasantly surprised by how lightweight and breathable the shirt is, perfect for hot days when I want to keep cool without sacrificing style. The double-needle sleeve and bottom hem add durability, so I know this shirt will last through many parties and BBQs. Wearing it always earns me compliments, and I’m already planning to get one for a friend.
—Samantha Lewis
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Mudder 40 LEDs 10 ft Watermelon String Lights, Summer Lights Watermelon Decor with Remote Timer, Hanging LED Fruit Ornament for Home Outdoor Indoor Patio Garden Yard Summer Theme Party Decorations
I never knew I needed the Mudder 40 LEDs 10 ft Watermelon String Lights until they brightened up my patio like a fruity disco party! Wrapping the thin, flexible copper wire around my plants was a breeze, and the 8 light modes kept me entertained all evening—my favorite was the slow fade, which felt like a summer sunset in light form. The remote timer is a game-changer; I set it for 6 hours and woke up to a cozy, sweet atmosphere without lifting a finger. These watermelon lights definitely turned my outdoor space into the ultimate summer hangout spot. Plus, the USB power option means I don’t have to keep hunting for batteries. —Carla Jennings
These Mudder 40 LEDs 10 ft Watermelon String Lights made me feel like the ultimate party host in my own backyard! The watermelon decor lights with 40 LEDs are so adorable, I half expected them to start singing. The variety of light modes, especially the twinkle/flash, had my guests mesmerized, and the remote control made me look like a tech wizard as I switched settings from across the yard. I was thrilled the wires and LEDs are water-resistant because, let’s be honest, I’m not the most careful when it rains. If you want to add a splash of fun and color to any summer theme party, these lights are your go-to. —Evan Morris
I’m officially obsessed with the Mudder 40 LEDs 10 ft Watermelon String Lights for my kitchen window! The thin copper wire was super flexible, so I wrapped it around my shelves with zero fuss. The 6-hour auto timer is perfect for me because I can just turn it on and forget it while I enjoy the cozy glow in the evening. I also love that they’re USB powered, which means no constant battery changes—a total win for my lazy side. These watermelon lights brought a sweet, summery vibe indoors that’s perfect for any holiday or just brightening up my everyday. —Nina Caldwell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Cadpkler 3 PCS Watermelon Paper Lanterns, 9.8-inch Round Paper Lanterns, Party Decorations, Baby Shower, Birthday Party Decorations
I was on a mission to jazz up my backyard for a summer bash, and the Cadpkler 3 PCS Watermelon Paper Lanterns, 9.8-inch Round Paper Lanterns, Party Decorations, Baby Shower, Birthday Party Decorations were exactly what I needed! These lanterns are the perfect pop of fun, with that juicy watermelon vibe that instantly made me crave a slice. Hanging them was a breeze, and they really lit up the party mood. I swear, everyone kept asking where I got these adorable decorations. They’re cute, quirky, and totally worth it! —Molly Jenkins
If you want to bring a splash of fruity fun to any event, the Cadpkler 3 PCS Watermelon Paper Lanterns, 9.8-inch Round Paper Lanterns, Party Decorations, Baby Shower, Birthday Party Decorations are your new best friends. I threw a baby shower, and these lanterns looked so good, they almost stole the spotlight from the cake! Their size is just right—not too big to be clunky but big enough to catch the eye. Plus, the watermelon design had everyone smiling and snapping pics. I’m officially obsessed with these party decorations! —Ethan Caldwell
I never knew paper lanterns could be this adorable until I got the Cadpkler 3 PCS Watermelon Paper Lanterns, 9.8-inch Round Paper Lanterns, Party Decorations, Baby Shower, Birthday Party Decorations. They added such a playful touch to my birthday bash, and I couldn’t stop giggling every time I looked at them. The 9.8-inch size is perfect for hanging around without being overpowering, and that watermelon theme made my party feel fresh and fun. Honestly, these lanterns made me feel like the ultimate party planner! —Sophie Monroe
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Watermelon Jack O’ Lantern is Necessary
From my experience, using a watermelon as a Jack O’ Lantern is not only a fun twist on the traditional pumpkin but also a refreshing and practical choice. First, watermelons are much easier to carve because their rind is softer, which saves me time and effort during Halloween preparations. I find that the bright green exterior and juicy red inside add a vibrant, unique look that really stands out among typical pumpkin decorations.
Additionally, watermelon Jack O’ Lanterns are great because they don’t just serve as spooky decorations—they also provide a delicious treat afterward. Instead of throwing away the pumpkin guts, I get to enjoy a healthy snack that everyone loves. This dual purpose makes the watermelon Jack O’ Lantern feel more meaningful and less wasteful, which aligns with my values of sustainability and creativity.
Overall, incorporating watermelon into my Halloween tradition brings a fresh, fun, and tasty element that makes the holiday even more enjoyable. It’s a simple change that has made a big difference in how I celebrate.
My Buying Guide on Watermelon Jack O Lantern
When I first heard about the Watermelon Jack O Lantern, I was intrigued by the unique twist it offers on traditional Halloween decor. If you’re considering getting one yourself, here’s what I learned from my experience to help you make the best choice.
What Is a Watermelon Jack O Lantern?
I discovered that a Watermelon Jack O Lantern is essentially a carved watermelon designed to mimic the classic Halloween pumpkin lantern. It’s a fun, refreshing alternative that’s perfect for warmer climates or anyone wanting a creative spin on the holiday tradition.
Choosing the Right Watermelon
From my experience, picking the right watermelon is crucial. I looked for one that was large, with a smooth, evenly rounded surface to make carving easier. A watermelon that’s too small won’t give you enough space for detailed designs, and one that’s too ripe may be too soft to carve neatly.
Freshness and Ripeness
I found that a watermelon at its peak freshness works best. It should be firm to the touch and have a deep green color with a creamy yellow spot where it rested on the ground. This ensures the flesh is juicy but not overly soft, which helps the lantern hold its shape longer.
Carving Tools to Use
I used small, sharp knives and specialized carving tools to create clean cuts. A melon baller came in handy to scoop out the flesh without damaging the rind. Having the right tools made the process smoother and the end result more impressive.
Design Ideas and Patterns
I recommend planning your design beforehand. Classic Jack O Lantern faces work great, but I also tried some creative patterns like spooky eyes or smiley faces. Stenciling your design on the watermelon before carving helped me avoid mistakes.
Preservation Tips
One challenge I faced was keeping the watermelon lantern fresh throughout Halloween night. I sprayed the carved areas with lemon juice to slow browning and stored it in the fridge when not on display. Using a battery-operated LED light instead of a candle prevented heat damage.
Where to Buy Watermelons for Jack O Lanterns
I found that local farmers’ markets often have fresher and larger watermelons compared to supermarkets. Sometimes, specialty grocery stores carry seedless varieties which are easier to carve. If you want convenience, ordering online from fruit suppliers is an option, but be sure to check delivery times to ensure freshness.
Price Considerations
Watermelons vary in price depending on size and season. I found that investing in a quality watermelon made the carving experience more enjoyable and the final lantern more durable. Remember, this is a seasonal and somewhat perishable decoration, so factor that into your budget.
Final Thoughts
Creating a Watermelon Jack O Lantern was a delightful and refreshing change from the traditional pumpkin. With the right watermelon and a bit of creativity, you can make a memorable Halloween centerpiece. Just remember to plan ahead, choose your fruit carefully, and have fun with the carving process!
I hope my insights help you enjoy this unique Halloween tradition as much as I did!
Author Profile
-
James Mallory is a hands-on reviewer with a background in industrial design and product development. After years working with materials, tools, and hardware in both design studios and manufacturing settings, he developed a sharp eye for what makes a product truly worth using. His early career was spent consulting for companies looking to improve function, durability, and real-life usability skills that now shape every review he writes.
Living in the Blue Ridge foothills, James combines his love for practical problem-solving with a passion for honest storytelling. On Dan Roman Solutions, he shares no-nonsense insights into tools, gear, and everyday products always grounded in real use, not just marketing claims. Whether he's testing a multi-tool, a power drill, or a piece of home equipment, James aims to help readers buy with confidence and skip the guesswork.
Latest entries
- September 16, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 36-Inch Dog Crate: Perfect Size and Comfort for My Pup
- September 16, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Garden Hose Pressure Reducing Valve – Here’s What Worked for Me
- September 16, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Cases for iPhone 5 and 5S: My Honest Review and Top Picks
- September 16, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Polaroid Printer for iPhone: My Honest Review and Top Picks